Crude oil prices have historically contributed to inflation, with significant events illustrating this relationship. In 1973, the oil producer cartel OPEC imposed an embargo on Western countries in support of Palestine. Similarly, in 1979, the Iranian Revolution led to the deposition of the Shah. In both instances, oil prices more than doubled in a short time. For example, inflation-adjusted prices rose from about $25 per barrel in 1971 to over $154 by 1980 (West Texas Intermediate).
These sharp price increases resulted in supply shortages and led to the most severe inflation since the Great Depression. Unlike the current inflation situation, which has been managed quickly and with minimal disruption, the inflation crisis of the 1980s took years and a deliberate recession to control.
The relationship between oil prices and inflation is complex. Crude oil prices are often volatile, and inflation does not consistently mirror these fluctuations. For instance, following the first Gulf War, oil prices more than doubled without causing significant inflation. However, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022 resulted in localized gas price inflation, which could hinder European industries for years.
During the pandemic, demand for crude oil plummeted, leading to a temporary scenario where WTI crude prices fell below zero in April 2020. This drastic decline did not result in a disinflationary shock.
Today, supply shortages and rising oil prices are less burdensome than in the past, largely due to increased energy efficiency and the expansion of renewable energy sources. Despite the volatility of oil prices, they have steadily risen over time, outpacing inflation.
Since 1980, the average price of WTI crude (adjusted for inflation) has been around $67 per barrel, rising to $76.30 since 2000. This increase may be linked to higher production costs, as extracting oil in the Gulf of Mexico is much more expensive than traditional methods. In Europe, fuel prices are influenced more by taxes than market forces.
Consumers and central bankers view energy prices through different lenses. Central bankers recognize that their control over fuel inflation is limited since crude oil prices are determined by international markets. Their monetary tools—such as adjusting credit costs—aim to manage demand rather than address supply shortages. Consequently, they often exclude highly volatile items like food and energy from inflation monitoring.
For consumers, however, rising grocery and fuel prices are tangible indicators of economic strain. After a recent 20% surge in prices, many are relieved that fuel prices have stabilized. Nevertheless, some central bankers remain concerned, as “core” items like rents and healthcare costs have not decreased as significantly.
Oil producers have a different perspective. Current oil prices, below the 25-year average, are troubling for many. As the world’s largest crude producer, the U.S. faces significant production costs—around $44 per barrel from fracking and drilling in the Gulf, which is considerably higher than costs in Saudi Arabia and Russia. As a result, many U.S. producers may limit expansion plans, while countries like Saudi Arabia require oil prices around $80 to meet budgetary and investment needs.
Despite low prices, market analysts remain optimistic about the future. Global crude inventories are declining, and production disruptions are occurring in places like Libya and the Gulf of Mexico due to natural disasters. OPEC has also extended its production cuts until December. In Sudan, civil unrest has devastated oil exports, while tensions in the Middle East pose risks for major producers like Iran.
The ongoing mismatch between demand and supply presents a unique situation. While this benefits consumers, it complicates matters for oil producers. Market observers often blame China for weakening oil prices, attributing the decline to its economic challenges. Despite facing a real estate crisis, China’s GDP growth remains around 5%, higher than many industrialized nations.
Analysts suggest that China’s advancements in renewable energy might be reducing its reliance on fossil fuel imports. Additionally, discounted oil imports from Russia and Iran could be influencing market prices.
Jeff Currie, a commodity analyst at Carlyle, offers an alternative explanation for the current market dynamics. He suggests that high interest rates have attracted investments away from oil and into safer money markets. Currie estimates that up to $100 billion has shifted from oil investments to risk-free funds, as the yields from these investments are more attractive compared to oil.
If Currie is correct, a decline in interest rates could redirect investment back into oil. Coupled with low inventory levels, this shift could drive oil prices up rapidly. Such a scenario would likely please retail investors and oil-producing nations, though it may also create challenges for policymakers, including those in the U.S. as the political landscape evolves.
You Might Be Interested In
- 12 Best Brent Crude Oil ETFs for October 2024
- Is Brent Oil a Good Investment?
- What is Brent Crude Oil Used For?